Realizacja struktur intonacyjnych w próbie czytania i mowie spontanicznej u osób starszych

Introduction

The issues presented in this article take into account the description of speech prosody in Polish on the example of the elderly. Prosody is a multidimensional phenomenon that is difficult to analyse. Describing intonation courses is a challenge for contemporary speech therapists dealing with this aspect in the communication process. Prosody includes elements such as accent, intonation, tempo, and rhythm of speech. These are factors necessary in the context of conveying meanings and building consistency of expression. If the researcher undertakes the description of communication behaviours and the diagnosis of prosodic skills (e.g. in the context of future therapeutic activities), it is necessary to refer to all the elements together, because they form a coherent whole dealing with the prosody of human speech.

Aim of the research

The article aims to present the prosodic features of speech characteristics of older people (components of the suprasegmental level of language), which accompany natural organic changes in the respiratory, phonation, and articulation apparatus. Attention was paid mainly to the dependence of the intoned words and phrases at the moment of changing semantic concentration and to the phonation power put into the production of a spontaneous utterance and reconstruction of the read text.

Material and methods

This article shows the results of research carried out based on observation of speech performance in the elderly in terms of creating statements, which translates into the receptive aspect (understanding) of the content. The analysis covered selected oral material from 32 Dictaphone recordings of women and men over 60 years of age. To distinguish the prosodic features of speech, the research material was analysed using the Praat program by Paul Boersma and David Weenink, which was used to analyse speech in terms of phonetics at the segmental and suprasegmental levels. Due to the length of the audio material, only parts of the statements were selected from individual recordings, and then they were described in terms of the following variants, the separation of which was made possible by the program mentioned, i.e. intonation structures (the so-called intonation contour), intensity of speech, and the effort involved in producing sounds. The graphic version is presented in the form of intonograms. Spectral analysis with the Praat speech test program involved first loading the entire speech (e.g. a 57-minute recording) into the Praat Objects window and using the extract part command to extract the time span of only those issues that were intended for tests. Then, in the Praat Picture window, using the View or View & Edit commands, the speech properties visible on the spectrogram were obtained. Bioethical commission number: 1/2021.

Description of the research procedure

Using an original questionnaire, the prosodic-intonation character of the utterance was assessed based on a fragment of a selected reading text (Table 1), and a spontaneous statement in the form of a discussion or response to life values (Table 2) was taken into account.

Symbols of the GAT 2 convention used in the analysis of oral statements

Intonation: [] rising intonation (ascending intonation contour/so-called anti-cadence), characteristic of questions requiring longer answers; [] falling intonation (falling intonation contour/so-called cadence), characteristic of declarative sentences; [] intonation slightly rising; denotes a slight upward pitch in intonation; ‘intonation rising in expressive accent; ’intonation falling in a word accent; – uniform intonation in the word accent. Pauses: [-] short pause; [–] medium pause; [.] micropause. Other conventions: h° short exhale; : short vowel extension; ::: extension of vowels with a longer duration (1–2 s); = quick transition to the next notice. The pace of speech: < > accelerating (accelerando); < > fast (allegro) < > slowing down (rallentando).

Results

Reading attempt

In the further part of the article, the material will be presented (Figures 1, 2) showing the semantic inaccuracies concerning particular types of utterances, i.e. the affirmative, interrogative, or imperative (Tables 3, 4). Characteristic are numerous, short- or medium-length pauses appearing in various places of the text being read. There was a break in the continuity of the sentence, for example, ‘This is (--) my brother’, or there is no break where it should be: ‘Jan, you’ve never been able..’ (no pause). In addition, there was a pause at the intonation point increasing in the exclamation point sentence, i.e. ‘Pfe (--) rat catcher (-)’. The statement ‘Join the circus, what a shame!’ ‘You are kidding!’ presents anticadence as the intonation increases, but the subject chants the question instead of the exclamation. There were also short vowel extensions [i] and [e] in the words ‘Grace’ and ‘Grimbledon’.

Spontaneous speech attempt

Subsequently, a different character of utterances was analysed, i.e. phrases and sentences uttered in a spontaneous/narrative speech, i.e. emotionally charged by assumption, the accent (logical and emphatic) of which may turn out to be variable in terms of semantic concentration. Therefore, the following intonograms provide information on the intonational course of utterances. Similarly, properties such as the intensity of the sounds uttered at each stage of the speech (marked with a yellow line on the oscillogram) and the distribution of formants (red points), i.e. the energy that the examined person puts during the production of phonation, are also taken into account, which is also the result of vibrations generated in various places in the oral cavity (Figure 3). The utterances were analysed in terms of the intonation contour, the intensity of the spoken sound, i.e. the volume, as well as the variable pace of the spoken words. The participant of the study used micropauses (.) and short pauses (-) before words stressed in even intonation [–ALSO], [–CHILDREN] and [–EVERYTHING], before which the pace of speech slowed down: [< –ALSO>], [< –EVERYTHING>]. You can see a clear contour falling after the noun ‘health’ (blue line), then, depending on the rate at which the words are pronounced, an ascending-descending contour. The point of intersection of the red lines marks the highest value of the intensity of the sound, which is 70.89 dB and takes place when the conjunction “też” is pronounced. The values ​​of the formants during a recording lasting more than 4 s (4.134221 s) are 1029.147573 Hz (for the first control – F1), 2032.658064 Hz (for the second control – F2), 2951.473680 Hz (for the third formant – F3), and 4342.825825 Hz (for the fourth formant – F4), which means that the energy increases with successively articulated sounds (Figure 4). Ascending-descending contour. The speech was kept at an unchanged pace, only the Polish word ‘wojennym’ was spoken slower (<>). There were a micro pause and an extension of the vowel [o] in the word ‘bronią’, the accent of which was kept in a falling key ().

Discussion

In linguistic communication, the prosody of speech is considered to be an indispensable, highly significant element for the evaluation of the entire communication process. There is a need to describe prosodic phenomena in the field of speech therapy because of its integral importance for the process of linguistic communication. “Intonational structures can be analysed on several levels: acoustic, acousto-phonetic, perceptual-phonetic, and phonological” [1–5]. In the area of articulation activities of the respondents, with healthy, physiological aging of the brain structures is a significant differentiating factor, slight changes occur on the suprasegmental plane of the language. The intonation reveals the emotional character of the statement, conditioned by the current mental state of the respondent. In this matter, the representation of the so-called emotional speech is related to the activity of the right hemisphere of the brain, and the non-verbal character of the act of communication significantly affects the process of communication [6]. The semantic function, which ultimately determines the consistency of the statement, plays a significant role here. Intonation has an impact on the functional character of the meaning expressed in the sentence, and above all on the logical connection of the topic and the rheme in the sentence [4, 7]. Therefore, both functionally and structurally, in spontaneous utterances and narrative speech, inductive thinking is preserved in the thematic-rhematic structure, which on the example of the respondents serves to maintain the conversational character. Emotional utterances are sometimes characterized by a change in semantic concentration in a given phrase, which is related to a changing logical or emphatic accent and a root melody in the phrase [7–12]. “An important aspect of language communication is the control of vocalization processes and the emotional characteristics of voice.” [13]. In the aspect of linguistic prosody, the most important elements of the act of utterance emerge in the foreground, which relates to lexical stress (the syllable in a word is stressed), emphatic stress (the word in a sentence is stressed), and intonation (chanting in a sentence, questions, statements) [14]. However, clinical studies [14] show that the indicated elements are directed by the part of the right hemisphere of the brain that is responsible for processing and understanding speech prosody, i.e. the posterior cortex in the area of the Sylvius sulcus and the lower part of the right frontal lobe. The analysis of intonation structures has shown that intonation, rhythm, melody, and stress are integral elements of the suprasegmental level of utterance and make up the human prosodic profile. Their implementation is influenced by the emotions, intentions of the speaker, and the attitude towards the interlocutor. This means that intonation is of great importance in the process of not only realizing individual levels of language organization, but also in the course of the communicative situation, and thus in the implementation of grammatical and semantic functions.
The Praat program – mentioned in the Material and methods section – was used for spectrographic analysis. The comprehensive version of the program can be downloaded from the websites [15, 16]. Despite many other, more advanced functions of the program, used, for example, to analyse various phonetic errors and even linguistic behaviour [17–19] – as mentioned previously – the focus was only on showing the properties of the intonation structures of utterances. Wysocka, for example, referred to the issue of intonation in more detail, distinguishing the most important intonation structures in terms of communication, such as a falling contour (cadence) – characteristic, among others for declarative sentences, commands, orders; increasing contour (anti-cadence) – relating, among others, to questions requiring resolution; and a constant contour (progrediance) – assigned to changes in pitch of the voice of fewer than 4 semitones [4, 20–26]. Moreover, the graphic elements of the GAT2 convention, developed in Germany, for the transcription and analysis of speech (German Gesprächsanalytisches Transkriptionssystem), which allows for speech analysis at several levels: minimum, basic, and detailed, were used to record prosodic phenomena. Only the graphical symbols corresponding to the features of the statements found in the presented research material were compared. The symbols were taken from the comparison between Mela and Schulte [27, 28]. In a dozen or so people who agreed to record their statements, differences were noticed at the linguistic level between the implementation of reading statements and spontaneous statements. The subjects tried to recreate the intonation phenomena of the passage being read [29] by putting more energy at the very beginning. In the course of reading, however, their focus shifted to the conscious maintenance of pace and appropriate volume, instead of the meaning aspect. Hence, minor inaccuracies, such as a flat intonation contour in utterances with an ascending intonation course, pauses breaking the contour’s continuity, or lengthening of vowels in words that are difficult to articulate. Inaccuracies in the linguistic perspective concerning spontaneous utterances on a given topic, when the respondent started and ended his/her thought, e.g. in a questioning way that intuitively requires ending in a falling key, may activate the emotional sphere of an elderly person to such an extent that certain life events will be reported with a feeling of agitation, suffering, joy, excitement, etc. in a flat or slightly increased tone. Such a topic that evoked various emotions at the outset was the category of a “fulfilled life” activating different reactions, as a result of which statements reported from the perspective of a suffering person in life or the one who, in turn, talked about fulfilment in every sphere of life, showed, for example, a different accent in the structure sentences. A dozen or so recordings of the narrative speech were listened to, in which the emphasis was more concentrated on the terms and objects characterizing the subject him/herself when he/she spoke about sad or very unpleasant things. On the other hand, people reporting from the perspective of the fulfilment of positive events more often emphasized the activities they performed concerning themselves or the environment. Nevertheless, this should not be taken as a rule.

Conclusions

Due to its general nature, the melody turned out to be a significant factor in the statements as regards the gender category. In men it was a melody with a falling structure, so a statement was more matter of fact than effusive with a raised intonation structure. These types of factors significantly affect the course of linguistic communication. There was a tendency in women’s speech to fluctuate prosody when an emotional factor appeared. At this point, the emphasis was on the lexeme which referred to the raised semantic register.

Acknowledgments

We would like to thank the clubs and seniors’ homes in the Świętokrzyskie Voivodeship for the opportunity to conduct language research and the pleasure of meeting wonderful, wise people.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References