Związki między cechami morfologicznymi stóp u osób w wieku geriatrycznym

Introduction

Human foot is a static and dynamic part of the motor organ. Appropriate design ensures keeping the body weight, while being capable to adapt to changes of the ground and movement. That specific structure is built-up by a system of longitudinal and transverse arches, which are compared to coil springs stretching under the influence of the load and returning to their initial state during the burden [1]. In terms of proper functioning of the foot, toes play a very significant role. Their proper arrangement enables effective functioning of other segments of the foot. While loading they adhere to the surface and during locomotion, their strong adherence relieves heads of the proper metatarsus bones [2]. The anterior ball of the metatarsophalangeal articulations on one hand is related to the anterior part of “the posterior static triangle of the foot”, and on the other hand, the posterior part of “the anterior dynamic triangle of the foot”. That spot is the focus point of all impulses propelling the gait. The first radius and the great toe play a significant role in it, particularly in the view of the fact that radius is activated in the final part of terminal stance [3]. The foot, despite elaborate construction, make up a functional whole, thus changes in one of them may contribute to activating individual compensating mechanisms leading to disorders in shape of the remaining segments and dysfunctions, and consequently, to complications in other elements of the motor system [2–4]. The foot architecture is a picture of the skeletal, musculo-ligament system and possible ongoing pathological processes within other systems or organs. Static-dynamic foot failure occurs in the elderly people due to involution changes. The weakening of the skeletal, muscle, and ligament systems increases the incidence of deformations [5, 6]. Problems within the feet are linked to deteriorated stability, falls, and decrease in gait speed [7]. Menz et al. [8] highlighted the impact of foot flexors strength on the balance in people aged 62–96 years. Menz et al. [9] observed that people experiencing falls were characterized by diminished flexibility within the ankle joints, decreased strength of plantar flexors, deformities of hallux valgus, and decreased sensitivity to touch of the plantar foot surface. Presented facts became a direct reason to take-up the topic of the paper, which is aimed to analyze the relationships between the features of the feet in men and women over 60 years of age.
Research questions:
1. What are the connections of the great toe setting and the fifth toe position with longitudinal foot arch in women and men over 60?
2. What are the connections of the great toe setting and the fifth toe position with transverse foot arch in women and men over 60?
3. What are the correlations between the hallux valgus angle and the V toe varus deformity angle in women and men over 60?

Material and methods

The examinations involved 198 seniors from the Podkarpackie and the Małopolskie voivodeships, including 116 females and 82 males. The inclusion criteria were: age in the range 60-90 years, dominating right hand and right leg determined on the basis of the Waterloo Handedness and Footedness Questionnaire – revised [10], physical fitness that allowed for walking without orthopedic equipment, and ability to take independently a standing position on a podoscop, a written consent to participate in the study.
Three age groups were distinguished. Thirty-eight women (average age, = 64.53 ±3.11 years) and 31 men (average age, = 65.29 ±3.15 years) were enrolled in the group 60–69. The group 70–79 consisted of 35 women (average age, = 75.13 ±3.45 years) and 28 men (average age, = 73.89 ±2.70 years), while the group of 80–90 years included 43 women (average age, = 85.47 ±3.38 years) and 23 men (average age, = 84.96 ±3.97 years).
The research tool was a podoscop (CQ-ST Electronic System). The calculations included following indices: the Clarke’s angle, Wejsflog’s index (W_wp), heel angle (), hallux valgus angle (), and the V toe varus deformity angle (). Anthropometric measurements of the body mass and height were obtained, and the data was used to calculate BMI index. Basic descriptive statistics of the somatic features in the examined seniors is presented Table 1.
The study was granted a permission by the Ethical Review Board of the Rzeszow University. In order to preserve the integrity of the research process, all the measurements were carried out in a gym, in the morning, using the same measuring instruments operated by the authors. Seniors were wearing gymnastic costumes without shoes, after receiving detailed information concerning the aim and methodology used in the study.
Based on the gathered data, the following descriptive statistics were calculated: arithmetical mean values ( ), standard deviations (SD), medians (Me). The normalcy of distribution of particular characteristics was verified by means of the Shapiro-Wilk test. In order to evaluate the correlations between characteristics of feet structure, the Spearman’s rank correlation was employed. Results were considered statistically significant if the probability level of the test was lower than the predetermined level  = 0.05. In this paper, the STATISTICA StatSoft 10.0 was used to process statistical test results.

Results

Table 2 presents the basic descriptive statistics of the parameters of feet structure in examined seniors.
In women qualified for the group 70–79 and 80–90, statistically significant negative relationships between  angle and Clarke’s angle was found, which means that the increase of the hallux valgus angle was accompanied by lowering of the longitudinal foot arch.
In women aged 70–79 and 80–90, negative correlations between  angle and the Wejsflog’s index of the right and the left foot were found. Statistically significant positive correlation between the hallux valgus angle and the heel angle of the right foot was reported in women aged 80–90.
In case of women aged 60–69 and 80–90, average correlations of the angle of the V toe varus deformity with the Wejsflog’s index were reported. In individual groups of women, connections between  and  angle in the left foot were found. The direction of this relationships indicates that the worse position of the fifth toe coexist with a forefoot widening (Table 3).
In men qualified for the group 70–79, a statistically significant negative correlation between hallux valgus angle and Clarke’s angle of the left foot was presented. A strong negative correlation was reported between  angle and the Wejsflog’s index of the right foot, and average positive correlations between  angle and the heel angle of the right and the left foot in men aged 60–69 were found. The direction of this relationships indicates that the lower transverse arch coincides with more significant hallux valgus.
In case of men aged 60–69 and 70–79, the V toe varus deformity angle in the left foot had weak positive correlations with the heel angle. In men aged 70–79, a positive correlation between the V toe varus deformity angle and the heel angle in the right foot was also found. The direction of this connections indicates that the lower values of  angle coexist with a higher transverse arch. Additionally, men aged 70–79 showed a negative correlation between the angle of the V toe varus deformity and the Wejsflog’s index of the right foot (Table 4).

Discussion

The issues related to the foot were discussed numerously, but few studies presented the correlations between feet construction features. The research by Demczuk-Włodarczyk [2] covering a group of 1,619 children and youth from Wroclaw, showed that despite the coexistence of the flat transverse and longitudinal foot, these defects are formed independently in the initial period. Nadolska-Ćwikła [11] in her study of the Polish female wrestler team and Trzcińska et al. [12] in the study of the students of physical education at the University of Physical Education in Warsaw observed that disturbances in longitudinal arch do not show correlation with the changes in the forefoot. Our analysis of the correlations of Clarke’s angle with the Wejsflog’s index and the heel angle in the elderly also indicates that these features are not related to each other. Therefore, it can be concluded that irrespective of the age, the changes in the longitudinal and transverse arch are independent of each other.
The relationships between the longitudinal arch and the great toe setting was investigated by Łuczak et al. [13]. In 191 people aged 22–80 years, a connection between hallux valgus and the lowered foot arch or the flat foot was found. Buchanan and Davis [14] on the basis of the research carried out in women and men aged 34.0 ±11.2 found statistically significant relationships between the setting of the great toe and the V toe and the position of the navicular bone. Also, Janchai et al. [15] analyzed the results of 213 Bangkok residents aged 60–80 years, and Golightly et al. [16] in the study including over 1,502 people with an average age of 68, reported correlations of the hallux valgus angle with the Clarke’s angle. In our study within women and men aged 60–69, there was no correlation between the setting of the great toe and the longitudinal arch of the foot, while in the case of persons in the age group of 70–79 and 80–90, correlations between these features were observed. This points to the fact that over the years, involution causes symptoms in the foot bones, deficiencies in the muscles and ligaments (which sustain its individual segments) changes in these parts of the foot increasingly, leading to a buildup of ailments and persistent deficiencies in the anatomical structure of the foot. Lack of correlations between the setting of the fifth toe and the Clarke’s angle is probably due to the fact that static arch on the lateral side of the foot takes the load without significant influence on the longitudinal dynamic arch located on the medial side of the foot.
The aim of the study was to analyze the correlation between the transverse arch with other features of the feet. We assumed that since the foot lifts and carries the weight of the entire body and provides mechanical conditions for maintaining balance, the forefoot has also the impact on its performance. Therefore, it seems that longitudinal arch, often regarded as the indicator of “foot health”, should not be a single diagnostic criterion in this regard. Wejsflog’s index is the commonly used indicator to assess the transverse arch of the foot. Also, the heel angle increases as the transverse arch of the foot flattens. According to some authors [17, 18], it is a measure of the transverse arch of the foot. Other authors argue that the heel angle is useful to evaluate the slenderness of the foot [19] or the heel setting [20]. This fact can be attributed to the different ways of determining these indicators. The Wejsflog’s index takes into account the width of the forefoot and the length of the foot, while the heel angle is included between the lateral and medial tangent, and takes into account the width of both the forefoot and hindfoot; thus, uniform loading of front and rear support zone may decrease its value. Our studies have shown that these characteristics are correlated. Demczuk-Włodarczyk [2] on the basis of the tests of children and adolescents’ feet found that abnormal adhesion of toes to the substrate occurs independently of the transverse architecture of foot. Our research show that the angle of the V toe varus deformity correlates with transverse foot arch in elderly men and women. The direction of the correlation indicated that the higher values of the β angle is accompanied by a widening of the forefoot. Hallux valgus angle and the angle of the V toe varus deformity do not show any correlations.
The results and analysis indicate that changes in different parts of the foot that results from involution processes, increasingly interact with one another in the elderly age. The proceeding aimed at preventing deformities and dysfunctions of the foot should pay particular attention to maintaining or restoring the capacity of muscles acting on the foot and improving proprioception. Similarly, it is necessary to take into account the relationships between different parts of the foot in footwear designed for senior citizens. Shoes should not interfere with the form and function of the front segment of the foot. Such conduct may help to maintain optimal (in relation to age) static and dynamic level of organ movement.

Conclusions

1. Correlations between the setting of the hallux and the longitudinal arch of the foot in people aged 70–79 and 80–90 indicate that changes in those parts of the feet due to involution processes increasingly interact with each other, and the setting of hallux has an impact on the longitudinal arch in seniors’ feet. No relationships between the angle of the V toe varus deformity and the longitudinal arch of the foot suggests that position of the V toe does not affect the longitudinal arch in feet of people over 60 years of age.
2. The hallux valgus angle and the V toe varus deformity angle occasionally correlated with the Wejsflog’s index and heel angle. Higher values of this angles are accompanied by a widening of the forefoot.
3. Hallux valgus angle and the V toe varus deformity angle do not show any correlations in women and men over 60.

Conflict of interest

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

References

1. Kasperczyk T. Wady postawy ciała. Diagnostyka i leczenie. Kraków 2004; 64.
2. Demczuk-Włodarczyk E. Budowa stopy w okresie rozwoju progresywnego człowieka. Studia i Monografie nr 66. AWF Wrocław 2003; 95-100: 105-108.
3. Parcou A. Przednia metatarsalgia mechaniczna i niedomoga środkowych kości śródstopia. Koncepcja, główne aspekty. In: Biomechanika i profilaktyka statycznych zniekształceń stóp. Dega W (ed.). PZWL, Warszawa 1981; 15-30.
4. Brügger A. Lehrbuch der funktionellen Storungen des Bewegungssystems. Brugger-Verlag, Zollikon/Benglen 2000; 112-119.
5. Scott G, Menz HB, Newcombe L. Age-related differences in foot structure and function. Gait Posture 2007; 26: 68-75.
6. Nix S, Smith M, Vicenzino B. Prevalence of hallux valgus in the general population: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Foot Ankle Res 2010; 21: 21-25.
7. Menz HB, Lord SR. The contribution of foot problems to mobility impairment and falls in community-dwelling older people. J Am Geriatr Soc 2001; 49: 1651-1656.
8. Menz HB, Morris ME, Lord SR. Foot and ankle characteristics associated with impaired balance and functional ability in older people. J Gerontol And Biol Sci Med Sci 2005; 60: 1546-1552.
9. Menz H, Morris ME, Lord SR. Foot and ankle risk factors for falls in older people: a prospective study. J Gerontol And Biol Sci Med Sci 2006; 61: 866-870.
10. Perrin P, Deviterne D, Hugel F, Perrot C. Judo, better than dance, develops sensorimotor adaptabilities involved in balance control. Gait Posture 2002; 15: 187-194.
11. Nadolska-Ćwikła I. Wysklepienie stop u zapaśniczek kadry Polski pod wpływem treningu. In: Aktywność fizyczna ludzi w różnym wieku. Umiastowska D (ed.). Albatros, Szczecin 2000; 280-283.
12. Trzcińska D, Tabor P, Olszewska E. Stopy studentów AWF w Warszawie – ocena plantograficzna. Wych Fiz Zdrow 2007; 3: 12-17.
13. Łuczak E, Kostecka K, Krekora K, Książczyk M. Ocena wysklepienia stopy u pacjentów z koślawością palucha. Kwart Ortop 2011; 2: 122-127.
14. Buchanan KR, Davis I. The relationship between forefoot, midfoot and rearfoot static alignment in pain-free individuals. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther 2005; 35: 559-566.
15. Janchai S, Chaiwanichsiri D, Silpipat N, Tiamprasitt J. Ageing feet and plantar arch characteristics of the Thai elderly. Asian Biomed 2008; 2: 297-303.
16. Golightly YM, Hannan MT, Dufour AB, Renner JB, Jordan JM. Factors associated with hallux valgus in a community-based cross-sectional study of adults with and with¬out osteoarthritis. Arthritis Care Res 2015; 67: 791-798.
17. Ślężyński J, Rottermund J. Cechy plantograficzne stóp kobiet w średnim i starszym wieku w zależności od charakteru pracy oraz czynników środowiskowych i osobniczych. Wych Fiz Sport 1999; 4: 41-67.
18. Wejsflog G. Charakterystyka liczbowa plantogramu stopy dziecięcej. Chir Narz Ruchu Ortop Pol 1963; 28: 301-307.
19. Hill LM. Changes in the proportions of female foot during growth. Am J Phys Antropol 1958; 16: 349-366.
20. Lizis P. Wysklepienia stóp oraz ich związek z wybranymi cechami morfologicznymi i funkcjonalnymi osób dorosłych. Studia i Monografie nr 1 Kielce 2009; 92.

Address for correspondence:

Ewa Puszczałowska-Lizis
Faculty of Medicine
Institute of Physiotherapy University of Rzeszow
26A Warszawska St.
35-205 Rzeszow, Poland
Phone: +48 608 700 369
Fax: +48 17 872 19 42